>> Listen to the episode on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and others.

Doug Simon is the Founder & CEO of the award-winning company D S Simon Media. D S Simon Media is a recognized innovator in broadcast public relations and the creator of the industry’s first AI-Powered Broadcast Media Tour™. Clients include top brands in healthcare, technology, travel, financial services, food and beverage, consumer goods, entertainment, retail, and non-profits.
TRANSCRIPT:
DOUG: One of the key aspects of public relations is affecting change. What if that change is overcoming a long-held belief? And that was the issue that Philip Shirley spearheaded, changing the Mississippi flag to remove Confederate symbols. Thanks so much for joining us.
PHILIP: Thank you for having me.
DOUG: Yeah. Could you give us a top-line overview of the Mississippi flag campaign? What was the situation?
PHILIP: In 2020, after years of debate, the Mississippi legislature went into special session that was extended because of COVID, and it created an opportunity to bring up the opportunity to change the state flag. There had been a lot of efforts for many years to do that. There had been a vote 19 years prior, and only 36% of the people voted to change the flag to remove a Confederate symbol from the flag. In 2020, in the legislative session, the legislature, after a monstrous lobbying effort, agreed to retire the state flag, and this was in June of 2020. And then in November, at the election, voters would have the opportunity to approve or say no to the new flag that would be created by the flag commission minus any Confederate symbols.
DOUG: Philip, can you comment on some of the different touch points in the creation of the flag that had these Confederate images and just walk us through how that was affecting people?
PHILIP: In 1861, in the Civil War, the Confederate States of America created a flag that was derivative of the United States of America flag. It had red and white stripes, and it had the canton in the upper hoist side of the flag, the far top left corner, it also had blue with stars on it. So, there was a battle known as Manassas. People also call it the Battle of Bull Run in July of 1861. The generals found it confusing about what was going on in the battle because in the heat of battle, and the smoke, and the blood, and so on, they couldn’t tell which side was which. So, the army of Northern Virginia, by September, had decided they had to fix that. So, they created their own battle flag. That is the flag that today we know as the confederate flag or the Rebel flag, some people call it. It never really flew over the Confederacy. The Confederacy had a different flag in 1861, but in 1863, they took that battle flag of the army of Northern Virginia as it was officially known, and they put it in the top left of their flag of the confederacy. It was called the Stainless Banner. It was just a white flag with that in the top left. Had the little Rebel flag with blue cross on it and a red background. In 1894, the Mississippi legislature created a Mississippi flag, and they did the same thing. Although it was a flag with stripes, they put that Confederate battle flag up in the top left corner. So, that’s where it became an issue in Mississippi, and that stayed on the flag up until 2020. Couple of things happened. In 2015, you remember Dylann Roof killed 9 people, and he posed in a church. And he posed with that flag on his website, and it went viral. And so, the rebel flag, Confederate flag, was big time in the national news and discussion. Fast forward a couple of years, the Charlottesville protests when they had this thing called Unite the Right and the neo-Nazis marched, and they had the Nazi flag flying right next to the Confederate flag. So, again, it became a big issue. Those two things triggered events. And at the same time, you remember we had police shootings in LA and Minnesota. We had Colin Kaepernick kneeling. We had the Black nationalists were on the rise. They went from, you know, a 190 something chapters to 220. The neo-Nazis went from about 22 chapters up to a 121. This period of time was a very racially diverse time. The Dylann Roof shooting was a turning point for Mississippi because our speaker of the house, big republican leader said, and I’m not quoting exactly, but basically said, I think it’s time we need to consider having a new flag. And then after the 2017 event in Charlottesville, South Carolina took their flag down. Nikki Haley retired and said we’re not flagging that over our state capital anymore. That period was a turning point. That’s why we did the research in 2018 and started really seriously looking at how could we launch a campaign to change the state flag here.
DOUG: Yeah. And you spearheaded the effort regarding the vote, and you had a fairly long way to go from the previous time this had been put to a vote where any change was lost. So, how did you get started in assessing what was going work to get voters engaged and to vote the way you wanted them to eliminate these confederate symbols that were part of the flag for years?
PHILIP: We had been monitoring the situation. My client initially was the Mississippi Economic Council. That is the state chamber of commerce. So, as you can imagine, they would be looking at things that would impede the development of commerce in the state. And we knew that economic development was impacted because privately, major corporations would tell us, we’re not going to look at Mississippi while you have that flag flying. They would not go on the record with that, although we have documented many instances where economic development was hurt. The tourism industry knew that it was hurting us, especially among minority populations that wouldn’t want to come to the state because flying a symbol of the Confederacy sent really negative symbols. So, we knew a number of things were being hurt by flying that flag.
DOUG: As part of your research, I know you undertook a poll in 2018 to see what the sentiment was. Can you tell us about that?
PHILIP: The poll in 2018 was to look at were opinions changing? Have they been changing over the last 18 years? And we found that we were moving in the right direction. There were more people willing to consider a change. We discovered a couple of things that were critical to our strategy, though. One is we found that up right at two thirds of every demographic, I’m talking about young, old, Black, White, Republican, Democrat, about two thirds were universal in saying, yes, I agree that this flag is hurtful to some of our citizens. That became a foundational piece for us because it opened the door to say, even the people who didn’t want to change the flag admitted that it was hurtful. So, that became a very important thing. And then seeing that willingness to change the flag was up into the low 40%. The vote earlier, there had been 36% who voted to change it. It was moving in the right direction, and that allowed us to begin thinking, if we actually ran a vigorous campaign, could we get over that 50% margin? Could we get 50% plus one vote? And so, we started a small grassroots campaign to see if we could move the voters without creating a counter campaign. We wanted to do the grassroots quietly so that those who wanted to keep the flag would just shrug it off and not do much. And so, in 2018, we began that quiet grassroots campaign and having quiet discussions to see if we could begin to move the voters towards change for the flag.
DOUG: You actually doubled the yes vote for changing the flag from that 36% to 72% percent. How would you maintain a consistent message across the different platforms and audiences when, obviously, there’s such strong emotional feelings around the flag?
PHILIP: We learned who would be on our side, and we armed them with talking points, white papers. We wrote guest editorials for major civic leaders. I would interview them, listen to their opinion, tell them what our key messages were, and then let them put into their own words how they would talk about that. And then we, you know, we did some ghost writing for them, but it was based on their own thoughts. We did interview them. We didn’t just write and send it out with their name on it. It was their words, but we did help with the writing. So, we did the guest editorials, letters to the editor. We wrote articles for internal newsletters, all of those sort of grassroots things that help create conversations over the kitchen table and Sunday school, wherever we could have those quiet conversations where people would listen and we could say, look, we know that this flag is hurtful. Do you want to fly that flag and offend your neighbor, the person you go to church with, the person you go to school with, or do you think maybe we should consider changing it? And so, we were we were trying to be very respectful of our opponents and not start an argument. So, we would listen to them and then offer our opinions. But we kept the consistency across all of the platforms by doing a couple of things. One is that we were fortunate enough to have, as our client, the four different entities that were most involved with it. The Mississippi Economic Council, the state chamber of commerce was our client number one. They in turn created two not for profit organizations. One was called the Alliance for Mississippi’s Future, and their goal was voter turnout. They were not allowed because of the way they were formed to say vote yes. There was another organization called the In God We Trust flag committee as we were now calling the flag based on what our research told us would help.
DOUG: And that was the new flag, just to clarify.
PHILIP: The new flag would have to have the words In God We Trust on it. That was in the legislation. And we lobbied hard for that because we knew from our research that would move people willing to think about it from 46% to 51% percent who would might say yes. So, we got that incorporated into the law, and we distributed this information and these messages across every channel imaginable working for, as I said, the two not for profits. One could say vote yes. One could say go vote. A dotted line out to the side, the Mississippi Department of Archives and History was charged by the legislature to create a flag commission. The flag commission would then design the flag based on public input, and they had thousands and thousands of designs submitted. And they worked with a couple of designers, ended up with the flag that they proposed. So, they were able to say, here’s what the flag means. So, we were able to create a campaign using the same creative look, although the messaging was different, but it made it feel sort of overwhelming that everyone wanted a new flag. Even though one of them really could just say, here’s what the flag means. One could say, you really need to go vote and be a part of history, and the other implying vote yes, but we couldn’t say vote yes. And the third one could say, go vote yes. And then Mississippi Economic Council, again, as the fourth client, was out there trying to just to keep the discussion going in the public. That is what they could do as a chamber of commerce. So, we were able to go across all of the channels that were available, and we sort of assessed our owned media, our paid media, and our earned media and looked at all of those categories and then, you know, compiled really a list of what are all the channels that are available to us free or paid. And that was the starting point. Sort of a typical marketing campaign, if you will.
DOUG: Obviously, something like this is filled with some enormous challenges. Do you have an example of maybe one of the biggest challenges you faced and how you adapted?
PHILIP: One specific thing I’ll mention, the granddaughter of senator John Stennis, you may remember that name, was fairly well known for his stand on race, and it was not positive, let’s just say it that way. Although he had many good accomplishments, I have to admit, but his granddaughter designed the flag, and there was a whole group of groundswells with a grassroots movement behind her flag design. We didn’t think that was going to be the best design, but we didn’t want to take an opinion on which design. We just wanted a new flag. And so, we were neutral on any one design. We had a difficult time because she had quite a following and had been working on it for years. And so that was an obstacle because we didn’t want to make her an enemy, but we also didn’t want to support her flag. So, again, we would meet with her. We would listen, and we just took a neutral stance.
DOUG: Philip, what was the most important lesson that you took away from this campaign?
PHILIP: I think the one thing that I learned from this because I’ve been in, you know, a lot of issues management, reputation management situations where our strategy really was to blast our opponents and to try to discredit their positions. This was very different. In fact, we delayed our campaign. In 2019, there was a gubernatorial race in Mississippi. We didn’t want to let this issue come out in 2019. We delayed our campaign for a full year to wait until there was a new governor because we knew that someone would make this a position in a gubernatorial race, and it would force people to take a side before we had told our story. So, we delayed for a year, again, under that banner of let’s respect our opponents, but let’s not make it an issue too soon. The other thing we learned was it’s really helpful to save your powder, to use that cliche. The old flag was retired in June. So, we had the summer. We had part of June, all of July, and August. We decided just to do a grassroots campaign. We were quietly raising a million dollars that we were going to create a, I’ll use a military term, shock and awe campaign at the last minute when it was too late for the other side to raise money. So, we went the first three months very quietly with grassroots. We were doing desk side interviews. We were doing guest editorials, letters to the editor, speaking engagements, very quiet grassroots campaign, but effective and thorough and statewide, and we rallied our troops. We got all the organizations that would work with us, and we gave them information, the tourism association, the colleges and universities worked with all of these groups quietly to align our messaging, but we saved our money until the last 8 weeks. So, we came out in September with our very targeted paid media, and we used everything. We used outdoor, we used digital, we used TV, and we used radio. Our goal was to be overwhelming, but so late that the opponents had been sort of lulled into just trying to combat us with earned media, but when we came out with our paid media, it was too late for them to raise enough money to do anything in opposition. So, the second thing we learned was save your powder, spend your money when it is most impactful. And for us, that was the last two weeks, of course.
DOUG: Lastly, what advice would you give PR pros who are looking to turn their cause into successful change?
PHILIP: I would say find your true believers and amplify their voice. And that’s what we did. If someone had a post, we would make sure that post was seen. If someone had an owned media channel, if they had a newsletter, we gave them information for that newsletter. Again, amplify the voice of those true believers because we had a handful of leaders, business leaders, political leaders, religious leaders, and we tried to arm them with information and then give them a pathway to effective communications. So, we would we would write for them, encourage them, make suggestions, help them to use their own channels whenever we could, but that requires just identifying who are the handful of true believers who believe in these calls. Let’s make sure their voices are heard, not just our voices in parallel to them.
DOUG: Yeah. It’s such an honor to hear your story, and I’m so proud myself to be able to contribute even a little bit to making sure this story gets out there because it’s a good way to keep people feeling hope in what they’re doing and pushing forward on the causes they believe in. Thanks so much for participating.
PHILIP: Thank you very much. I enjoyed reminiscing about this change that we were able to implement in Mississippi and the dramatic difference that it has made for our state.











